“…we have a phased redeployment, where we’re as careful getting out as we were careless getting in…”
– Sen. Barack Obama, during the 2008 presidential campaign, referring to his plan for withdrawal from Iraq, in an interview with Politico before the Potomac Primaries, Feb. 11, 2008.
“As a candidate for president, I pledged to bring the war in Iraq to a responsible end, for the sake of our national security, and to strengthen American leadership around the world.”
– President Obama, announcing the end to the Iraq War, with all troops coming home by the end of the year, Friday, October 21, 2011.
No aircraft carrier. No glorious banner. Just a man announcing the resolution of a campaign promise, standing at the podium in the White House briefing room. What a refreshing change. Less than three years after taking his oath of office, President Obama announced today that not only he, but the nation he leads, our nation, “keeps its commitments.”
By doing so, he said, “the United States is moving forward from a position of strength.” That goes not only for the Iraqi theater, but also on the wide and brightly lit stage of global politics.
For his political opponents, though, all the president’s victories are framed as failures. It doesn’t matter how measured the delivery, or how much these foreign policy resolutions raise America’s stock in the eyes of our global partners, the GOP is ready to throw mud on it.
Getting bin Laden was a failure for Obama because he rejected “harsh interrogation techniques;” helping a NATO mission to get rid of Gaddafi was, according to former UN Ambassador John Bolton, a “massive strategic failure;” and today’s announcement has been greeted by Republican presidential primary candidate Mitt Romney as an “astonishing failure” of negotiation with the Iraqis, who could not get their parliament to agree on taking out the trash, much less protecting US troops from war crimes charges that would obviously be against our national interest. Romney actually called the president’s efforts at securing an agreement “sheer ineptitude.”
Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) at least attempted to point out that it’s the Iraqis who failed, here, while he also blamed his former opponent. “It is a consequential failure of both the Obama Administration,” he said, “as well as the Iraqi government.”
We are no longer welcome in Iraq, and no amount of blood-lust pride is worth the arm twisting it would take to make their government work the way we would like. It was their deadline to meet, under the agreement negotiated by the Bush Administration, and they could not meet it. But the GOP and other right wing war machine have adopted the anachronistic, imperial view, that as long as we’re in charge, and we have guns, things will go our way. Might makes right is a basic tenet of their thinking, whether they’re talking about foreign policy or domestic issues. As conservative über-blogger Andrew Breitbart ranted in September, “We outnumber [liberals] in this country, and we have the guns.”
Breitbart, of course, is wrong. Guns don’t rule. People do. He is influenced by the same Second Amendment radicalism as the politicians, who operate under the influence of the diesel fumes and gunpowder smoke their perpetual campaigns must inhale to live. They are like ostriches on a pipe dream, still unwilling to accept that in our shrunken world, we can no longer be lulled by 1950s style, commie-behind-every-tree, mom and apple pie, Madison Avenue icons, nor can we be bullied into believing what is best for captains of industry is best for us.
Iraq was Bush and Cheney’s war of revenge. It was a war to put money in the pockets of big government contractors, like Haliburton, Kellogg, Brown & Root, and Blackwater. The failure to reach terms with the Iraqi parliament affects them as much as the troops. Should they continue to work for the State Department, they would no longer have any kind of diplomatic protection. Ironic, perhaps, because it is precisely because of Blackwater’s alleged overreaction in a Baghdad firefight, in 2007, which killed 17 Iraqi civilians, that blew away any chance of criminal immunity for America’s military, or the contractors who work for them.
“The tide of war is receding,” in our major foreign involvements, Obama reiterated, today. But as long as our Congress remains as dysfunctional as the Iraqi parliament, the ship of state will remain painfully aground, here, for there will be no reciprocal rising tide to lift us. Welcome to the economy, a new kind of quagmire.